Effects of Different Foliar Calcium Fertilizers on Storage Quality and Several Protective Enzymes of Chinese Cherry

doi:10.7668/hbnxb.20193383

Abstract

Abstract:

In order to explore the storability of Chinese cherry fruit,reduce the decay rate of post harvest fruit and prolong its storage life. Chinese cherry Black pearl was sprayed with CaCl₂,amino acid calcium and sugar alcohol calcium after flowering. The internal and external quality of post harvest fruits during storage and several protective enzymes were studied,and the most suitable calcium fertilizer and its concentration were selected.The results showed that:with the extension of storage time,cherry fruit hardness,100 fruit weight,soluble sugar,titratable acid,soluble protein,Vc,β-carotene decreased;the content of MDA and REC increased gradually;the activities of soluble solids,SOD,POD and PPO increased first and then decreased;the nutrient and water loss,PPO activity and MDA accumulation of cherry fruit treated with calcium fertilizer during storage were lower than CK;the activities of SOD and POD were higher than CK. Foliar calcium fertilizer improved the storage resistance of Black pearl cherry. The comprehensive evaluation of membership function showed that 1 500 times sugar alcohol calcium had the best effect on fruit preservation. Spraying calcium fertilizer before harvest could improve the hardness,quality and the activity of antioxidant enzymes of cherry fruit,so as to prolong the storage period of cherry.1 500 times sugar alcohol calcium can be popularized and applied in production.

Key words: Black pearl cherry, CaCl₂, Amino acid calcium, Sugar alcohol calcium, Storage performance, Antioxidant enzymes

YANG Xuelian, HU Xiaojing, WU Yongfei, MING Fangyan, PENG Qiang. Effects of Different Foliar Calcium Fertilizers on Storage Quality and Several Protective Enzymes of Chinese Cherry[J]. Acta Agriculturae Boreali-Sinica, 2022, 37(S1): 231-239. doi: 10.7668/hbnxb.20193383.

/ / Recommend / Download Citations

URL: http://www.hbnxb.net/EN/10.7668/hbnxb.20193383

http://www.hbnxb.net/EN/Y2022/V37/IS1/231

Figures/Tables 6

References 36

[1]	Chen T, Huang X J, Zhang J, Chen Q, Liu Y, Tang H R, Pan D M, Wang X R. Genetic diversityand population structure patterns in Chinese cherry(Prunus pseudocerasus lindl)landraces[J]. Plant Molecular Biology Reporter, 2016, 34(2):440-453. doi:10.1007/s11105-015-0934-2. doi: 10.1007/s11105-015-0934-2 URL
[2]	刘针杉, 何文, 王燕, 陈清, 张静, 汤浩茹, 王小蓉. 中国樱桃黑珍珠离体的培养技术[J]. 分子植物育种, 2019, 17(24):8215-8220. doi:10.13271/j.mpb.017.008215. doi: 10.13271/j.mpb.017.008215
	Liu Z S, He W, Wang Y, Chen Q, Zhang J, Tang H R, Wang X R. In vitro culture technique of Heizhenzhu(Cerasus pseudocerasus(lindl).G.don)[J]. Molecular Plant Breeding, 2019, 17(24):8215-8220.
[3]	Sharafi Y, Jannatizadeh A, Fard J R, Aghdam M S. Melatonin treatment delays senescence and improves antioxidant potential of sweet cherry fruits during cold storage[J]. Scientia Horticulturae, 2021, 288:110304. doi:10.1016/j.scienta.2021.110304. doi: 10.1016/j.scienta.2021.110304
[4]	赵悦菡, 侯召华, 纪海鹏, 董成虎, 张娜, 郭红莲, 陈存坤. 樱桃生理变化及保鲜机理研究进展[J]. 食品研究与开发, 2021, 42(23):197-203. doi:10.12161/j.issn.1005-6521.2021.23.031. doi: 10.12161/j.issn.1005-6521.2021.23.031
	Zhao Y H, Hou Z H, Ji H P, Dong C H, Zhang N, Guo H L, Chen C K. Advances in research on physiological changes and fresh-keeping mechanism of cherries[J]. Food Research and Development, 2021, 42(23):197-203.
[5]	Dong Y, Zhi H H, Wang Y. Cooperative effects of pre-harvest calcium and gibberellic acid on tissue calcium content,quality attributes,and in relation to postharvest disorders of late-maturing sweet cherry[J]. Scientia Horticulturae, 2019, 246:123-128. doi:10.1016/j.scienta.2018.10.067. doi: 10.1016/j.scienta.2018.10.067
[6]	Winkler A, Knoche M. Calcium and the physiology of sweet cherries:A review[J]. Scientia Horticulturae, 2019, 245:107-115. doi:10.1016/j.scienta.2018.10.012. doi: 10.1016/j.scienta.2018.10.012 URL
[7]	张伟, 刘畅, 杜国栋, 汪晓谦. 喷施钙肥对梨果实品质和石细胞代谢的影响[J]. 中国果树, 2022(1):34-39. doi:10.16626/j.cnki.issn1000-8047.2022.01.007. doi: 10.16626/j.cnki.issn1000-8047.2022.01.007
	Zhang W, Liu C, Du G D, Wang X Q. Effects of spraying calcium fertilizer on fruit quality and stone cell metabolism of pear[J]. China Fruits, 2022(1):34-39.
[8]	彭舒, 李丽, 张婷渟, 周秀秀, 杨芩. 喷施醋酸钙对蓝莓果实发育过程中关键品质的影响[J]. 中国果树, 2021(3):20-25. doi:10.16626/j.cnki.issn1000-8047.2021.03.004. doi: 10.16626/j.cnki.issn1000-8047.2021.03.004
	Peng S, Li L, Zhang T T, Zhou X X, Yang Q. Effect of spraying calcium acetate on key quality of blueberry fruits during development[J]. China Fruits, 2021(3):20-25.
[9]	Sabir F K, Sabir A. Pre-harvest micronized calcium and postharvest UV-C treatments extend the quality ofcrimson seedless'(Vitis vinifera L.)grapes[J]. Erwerbs-Obstbau, 2019, 61(1):25-32. doi:10.1007/s10341-019-00444-2. doi: 10.1007/s10341-019-00444-2 URL
[10]	Thwin Y W, Chang M S, Hong Y, Lim S. Effects of 1-MCP and calcium chloride treatments on quality maintenance of full-ripe cherry tomatoes[J]. Korean Journal of Food Preservation, 2020, 27(4):433-445. doi:10.11002/kjfp.2020.27.4.433. doi: 10.11002/kjfp.2020.27.4.433 URL
[11]	李合生. 植物生理生化实验原理和技术[M]. 北京: 高等教育出版社, 2000.
	Li H S. Principles and techniques of plant physiological and biochemical experiments[M]. Bejing: Higher Education Press, 2000.
[12]	刘萍, 李明军. 植物生理学实验技术[M]. 北京: 科学出版社, 2007.
	Liu P, Li M J. Experimental techniques of plant physiology[M]. Beijing: Science Press, 2007.
[13]	高俊凤. 植物生理学实验指导[M]. 北京: 高等教育出版社, 2006.
	Gao J F. Experimental guidance of plant physiology[M]. Bejing: Higher Education Press, 2006.
[14]	李佳益, 龚无缺, 杨静慧, 刘艳军, 梁发辉, 黄俊轩. 温室中7个樱桃品种果实内在品质比较[J]. 西南大学学报(自然科学版), 2018, 40(7):25-30. doi:10.13718/j.cnki.xdzk.2018.07.004. doi: 10.13718/j.cnki.xdzk.2018.07.004
	Li J Y, Gong W Q, Yang J H, Liu Y J, Liang F H, Huang J X. Comparative analysis of fruit internal quality of seven cherry varieties in a solar greenhouse[J]. Journal of Southwest University (Natural Science Edition), 2018, 40(7):25-30.
[15]	Yang C, Duan W Y, Xie K L, Ren C H, Zhu C Q, Chen K S, Zhang B. Effect of salicylic acid treatment on sensory quality,flavor-related chemicals and gene expression in peach fruit after cold storage[J]. Postharvest Biology and Technology, 2020, 161:111089. doi:10.1016/j.postharvbio.2019.111089. doi: 10.1016/j.postharvbio.2019.111089
[16]	Li L J, Tan W S, Li W J, Zhu Y B, Cheng Y S, Ni H. Citrus taste modification potentials by genetic engineering[J]. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 2019, 20(24):6194. doi:10.3390/ijms20246194. doi: 10.3390/ijms20246194 URL
[17]	谢东锋, 薛书浩, 曾钰婷, 朱振家, 王国强, 秦宝. 采前微生物菌肥处理连作土壤对番茄生长及抗性酶活性的影响[J]. 北方园艺, 2018(21):136-141. doi:10.11937/bfyy.20174662. doi: 10.11937/bfyy.20174662
	Xie D F, Xue S H, Zeng Y T, Zhu Z J, Wang G Q, Qin B. Effects of preharvest microbial fertilizers treatment of continuous cropping soil on tomato growth and resistance enzymes activity[J]. Northern Horticulture, 2018(21):136-141.
[18]	刘莹, 李鹏, 沈冰, 冯朝红, 刘琦, 张祎. 采用稳定碳同位素法分析白羊草在不同干旱胁迫下的水分利用效率[J]. 生态学报, 2017, 37(9):3055-3064. doi:10.5846/stxb201601180112. doi: 10.5846/stxb201601180112
	Liu Y, Li P, Shen B, Feng Z H, Liu Q, Zhang Y. Effects of drought stress on Bothriochloa ischaemum water-use efficiency based on stable carbon isotope[J]. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 2017, 37(9):3055-3064.
[19]	巴良杰, 曹森, 马超, 吉宁, 王瑞, 罗冬兰. 采前喷钙处理对火龙果贮藏品质的影响[J]. 食品科技, 2020, 45(8):50-55. doi:10.13684/j.cnki.spkj.2020.08.010. doi: 10.13684/j.cnki.spkj.2020.08.010
	Ba L J, Cao S, Ma C, Ji N, Wang R, Luo D L. Effects of preharvest calcium spray on storage quality of pitaya[J]. Food Science and Technology, 2020, 45(8):50-55.
[20]	莫飞旭, 田茂科, 龙友华, 吴小毛, 尹显慧, 赵志博, 黎晓茜, 黄文源. 叶面施钙对猕猴桃钙含量、品质及贮藏性的影响[J]. 中国南方果树, 2019, 48(2):116-120. doi:10.13938/j.issn.1007-1431.20180430. doi: 10.13938/j.issn.1007-1431.20180430
	Mo F X, Tian M K, Long Y H, Wu X M, Yin X H, Zhao Z B, Li X Q, Huang W Y. Effect of foliar application of calcium on calcium content,quality and storage of kiwifruit[J]. South China Fruits, 2019, 48(2):116-120.
[21]	刘珠琴, 赵秀花, 厉鑫, 黄宗兴. 外源钙对中国樱桃果实品质的影响[J]. 浙江农业科学, 2021, 62(4):723-724. doi:10.16178/j.issn.0528-9017.20210425. doi: 10.16178/j.issn.0528-9017.20210425
	Liu Z Q, Zhao X H, Li X, Huang Z X. Effect of exogenous calcium application on fruit quality of Chinese cherry[J]. Journal of Zhejiang Agricultural Sciences, 2021, 62(4):723-724.
[22]	徐凌, 郝义, 郝树池, 王岩, 吕仁强. 采前钙和钾处理对红灯樱桃果实采后生理的影响[J]. 果树学报, 2009, 26(4):568-571. doi:1013925/j.cnki.gsxb.200904010. doi: 1013925/j.cnki.gsxb.200904010
	Xu L, Hao Y, Hao S C, Wang Y, Lü R Q. Effects of pre-harvest calcium and potassium treatments on post-harvest physiology of sweet cherry cv.Hongdeng[J]. Journal of Fruit Science, 2009, 26(4):568-571.
[23]	邢尚军, 刘方春, 马丙尧, 杜振宇, 马海林, 段春华. 钙对甜樱桃贮藏品质、钙形态及细胞超微结构影响[J]. 生态环境学报, 2010, 19(9):2091-2096. doi:10.16258/j.cnki.1674-5906.2010.09.034. doi: 10.16258/j.cnki.1674-5906.2010.09.034
	Xing S J, Liu F C, Ma B Y, Du Z Y, Ma H L, Duan C H. Storage property,calcium fractions,and cell ultrastructure in sweet cherry as affected by calcium[J]. Ecology and Environmental Sciences, 2010, 19(9):2091-2096.
[24]	王丹, 辛力, 张倩, 卢昊, 张静. 采后钙处理对甜樱桃货架期品质的影响[J]. 山东农业科学, 2016, 48(7):72-75. doi:10.14083/j.issn.1001-4942.2016.07.016. doi: 10.14083/j.issn.1001-4942.2016.07.016
	Wang D, Xin L, Zhang Q, Lu H, Zhang J. Effects of postharvest calcium dipping on quality of sweet cherry during shelf life[J]. Shandong Agricultural Sciences, 2016, 48(7):72-75.
[25]	潘琪, 武建强, 贾慧, 宁芳, 张文菲, 张熠可, 韩爱谦, 袁嘉玮. 外源钙对低温胁迫下梨生理特性的影响[J]. 山西农业科学, 2022, 50(2):148-154.
	Pan Q, Wu J Q, Jia H, Ning F, Zhang W F, Zhang Y K, Han A Q, Yuan J W. Effect of exogenous calcium on physiological characteristics of pear under low temperature stress[J]. Journal of Shanxi Agricultural Sciences, 2022, 50(2):148-154.
[26]	马超, 王如福, 曹森, 巴良杰, 吉宁, 王瑞. 采前喷施糖醇螯合钙对猕猴桃贮藏品质的影响[J]. 食品科技, 2021, 46(8):52-58. doi:10.13684/j.cnki.spkj.2021.08.009. doi: 10.13684/j.cnki.spkj.2021.08.009
	Ma C, Wang R F, Cao S, Ba L J, Ji N, Wang R. Effect of spraying sugar alcohol chelated calcium before harvest on storage quality of kiwifruit[J]. Food Science and Technology, 2021, 46(8):52-58.
[27]	庞凌云, 李瑜, 詹丽娟, 王莉莉, 孟欢. 不同钙处理对中华猕猴桃软化的影响[J]. 食品与发酵工业, 2014, 40(9):102-106. doi:10.13995/j.cnki.11-1802/ts.2014.09.043. doi: 10.13995/j.cnki.11-1802/ts.2014.09.043
	Pang L Y, Li Y, Zhan L J, Wang L L, Meng H. Study on the effects of different calcium treatments on softening of Actinidia chinensis planch[J]. Food and Fermentation Industries, 2014, 40(9):102-106.
[28]	Liu H, Chen F S, Lai S J, Tao J R, Yang H S, Jiao Z G. Effects of calcium treatment and low temperature storage on cell wall polysaccharide nanostructures and quality of postharvest apricot(Prunus armeniaca)[J]. Food Chemistry, 2017, 225:87-97. doi:10.1016/j.foodchem.2017.01.008. doi: 10.1016/j.foodchem.2017.01.008 URL
[29]	张礼良, 王馨悦, 姜爱丽, 周福慧, 胡文忠. 氯化钙处理对采后蓝莓果实品质的影响[J]. 保鲜与加工, 2020, 20(4):1-8. doi:10.3969/j.issn.1009-6221.2020.04.001. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1009-6221.2020.04.001
	Zhang L L, Wang X Y, Jiang A L, Zhou F H, Hu W Z. Effect of calcium chloride treatment on quality of postharvest blueberries[J]. Storage and Process, 2020, 20(4):1-8.
[30]	黄艳, 文露, 庞亚卓, 黄本义, 王进, 吕秀兰. 喷施钙肥对夏黑葡萄果实糖酸积累的影响[J]. 中国土壤与肥料, 2020(2):166-172. doi:10.11838/sfsc.1673-6257.19155. doi: 10.11838/sfsc.1673-6257.19155
	Huang Y, Wen L, Pang Y Z, Huang B Y, Wang J, Lü X L. Effect of spraying calcium on sugar and acid accumulation in Summer black grape[J]. Soil and Fertilizer Sciences in China, 2020(2):166-172.
[31]	周君, 肖伟, 陈修德, 高东升, 李玲. 外源钙对黄金梨叶片光合特性及果实品质的影响[J]. 植物生理学报, 2018, 54(3):449-455. doi:10.13592/j.cnki.ppj.2017.0519. doi: 10.13592/j.cnki.ppj.2017.0519
	Zhou J, Xiao W, Chen X D, Gao D S, Li L. Effect of exogenous calcium on leaf photosynthetic characteristics and fruit quality of Whangkeumbae pear[J]. Plant Physiology Journal, 2018, 54(3):449-455.
[32]	Arabloo M, Taheri M, Yazdani H, Shahmoradi M. Effect of foliar application of amino acid and calcium chelate on some quality and quantity of Golden Delicious and Granny Smith apples[J]. Trakia Journal of Science, 2017, 15(1):14-19. doi:10.15547/tjs.2017.01.003. doi: 10.15547/tjs.2017.01.003
[33]	李玉鹏, 杨光, 李飞, 白利勇, 黄明丽, 刘可忠, 颜冬云. 糖醇螯合钙肥对马铃薯产量、品质及养分吸收的影响[J]. 土壤, 2020, 52(4):773-780. doi:10.13758/j.cnki.tr.2020.04.017. doi: 10.13758/j.cnki.tr.2020.04.017
	Li Y P, Yang G, Li F, Bai L Y, Huang M L, Liu K Z, Yan D Y. Effects of sugar alcohol chelated calcium fertilizer on yield,quality and nutrient uptake of potato[J]. Soils, 2020, 52(4):773-780.
[34]	张曼, 张爱华, 赵艳, 王蓓蓓, 耿建建, 董存明, 汤华, 阮云泽. 新型钾钙肥对香蕉生长、果实产量及品质的研究[J]. 中国南方果树, 2016, 45(3):83-86,89. doi:10.13938/j.issn.1007-1431.20150559. doi: 10.13938/j.issn.1007-1431.20150559
	Zhang M, Zhang A H, Zhao Y, Wang B B, Geng J J, Dong C M, Tang H, Ruan Y Z. Effects of new potassium calcium fertilizer on banana growth,fruit yield and quality[J]. South China Fruits, 2016, 45(3):83-86,89.
[35]	刘鑫铭, 陈婷, 雷龑. 钙处理对巨峰葡萄贮藏品质的影响[J]. 中国南方果树, 2022, 51(1):159-162,165. doi:10.13938/j.issn.1007-1431.20210494. doi: 10.13938/j.issn.1007-1431.20210494
	Liu X M, Chen T, Lei Y. Effect of calcium treatment on storage quality of Kyoho grape[J]. South China Fruits, 2022, 51(1):159-162,165.
[36]	裴健翔, 李燕青, 程存刚, 李壮. 不同钙制剂对寒富苹果果实硬度及相关细胞壁代谢物质的影响[J]. 果树学报, 2018, 35(9):1059-1066. doi:10.13925/j.cnki.gsxb.20180169. doi: 10.13925/j.cnki.gsxb.20180169
	Pei J X, Li Y Q, Cheng C G, Li Z. Effects of different calcium agents on fruit firmness and related cell wall metabolites in Hanfu apple[J]. Journal of Fruit Science, 2018, 35(9):1059-1066.

指标 Index	处理 Treatment	贮藏天数/d Storage time
指标 Index	处理 Treatment	1	2	3	4	5
百果质量/g	P1	247.50±0.00e	243.55±0.01e	235.25±0.06f	233.87±0.47d	233.62±0.25b
Fruit weight	P2	258.38±0.01d	252.71±0.28c	252.21±1.30c	223.79±0.40f	212.94±0.34e
	P3	258.90±0.00d	250.90±0.10cd	245.01±0.72d	229.86±0.86e	229.56±0.76c
	P4	237.98±0.50f	236.64±0.12f	235.97±0.06f	232.55±0.48de	214.18±0.34e
	P5	237.18±0.25f	236.54±0.02f	235.27±0.03f	231.55±0.78de	212.58±0.39e
	P6	274.89±0.02b	267.59±0.06b	255.91±0.71b	246.31±0.15a	242.86±0.50a
	P7	279.17±0.02a	272.00±1.28a	258.75±0.50a	248.23±0.10a	241.75±0.21a
	P8	267.98±0.02c	266.41±0.01b	252.27±0.21c	241.43±0.18b	227.39±0.02cd
	P9	257.91±0.01d	247.37±0.66d	243.26±0.22e	237.22±1.01c	226.38±0.47cd
	CK	237.48±0.04f	217.30±0.71g	217.05±1.06g	212.73±0.18g	204.68±0.16f
腐烂率/%	P1	5.33±0.01d	11.39±1.61a	13.13±0.18b	17.51±0.01d	26.48±0.03d
Decay rate	P2	8.00±0.14a	8.09±0.02d	11.32±0.02d	19.74±0.01c	36.51±0.01b
	P3	4.35±0.21e	10.29±0.07b	14.49±0.02a	23.74±0.02b	36.50±0.00b
	P4	7.32±0.02b	7.52±0.04ef	12.16±0.23c	19.15±0.21c	30.25±0.00c
	P5	6.32±0.02c	6.66±0.01g	9.34±0.00e	15.25±0.00e	26.12±0.17d
	P6	6.01±0.01c	8.01±0.01de	8.21±0.01f	16.25±0.00de	25.12±0.16e
	P7	5.74±0.02d	7.75±0.01e	8.20±0.00f	9.00±0.01f	15.00±0.00f
	P8	6.05±0.07c	8.32±0.02d	9.18±0.21e	19.76±0.01c	24.02±0.02e
	P9	4.01±0.01e	9.02±0.03c	11.12±0.17d	23.25±0.01b	30.24±0.01c
	CK	5.62±0.07d	10.60±0.85b	13.66±0.01b	31.35±0.21a	39.01±0.01a
硬度/(kg/cm²)	P1	1.72±0.10a	1.38±0.28a	1.27±0.03ab	1.12±0.10bc	0.95±0.03bc
Firmness	P2	1.78±0.10a	1.52±0.10a	1.25±0.20ab	1.24±0.11abc	1.02±0.20bc
	P3	1.67±0.14a	1.48±0.28a	1.15±0.12ab	1.06±0.09c	1.02±0.10bc
	P4	1.67±0.23a	1.62±0.09a	1.45±0.05a	1.43±0.13a	1.05±0.13bc
	P5	1.79±0.05a	1.64±0.23a	1.41±0.25a	1.24±0.03ab	1.23±0.11a
	P6	1.67±0.26a	1.60±0.25a	1.45±0.07a	1.42±0.07a	0.95±0.12bc
	P7	1.63±0.20a	1.49±0.35a	1.40±0.12a	1.36±0.08ab	1.06±0.18bc
	P8	1.73±0.12a	1.50±0.03a	1.11±0.26ab	1.11±0.17bc	1.09±0.20ab
	P9	1.61±0.20a	1.35±0.09a	1.18±0.16ab	1.15±0.28bc	1.09±0.10ab
	CK	1.58±0.08a	1.43±0.27a	1.00±0.19b	0.96±0.30c	0.88±0.18c

指标 Index	处理 Treatment	贮藏天数/d Storage time
指标 Index	处理 Treatment	1	2	3	4	5
百果质量/g	P1	247.50±0.00e	243.55±0.01e	235.25±0.06f	233.87±0.47d	233.62±0.25b
Fruit weight	P2	258.38±0.01d	252.71±0.28c	252.21±1.30c	223.79±0.40f	212.94±0.34e
	P3	258.90±0.00d	250.90±0.10cd	245.01±0.72d	229.86±0.86e	229.56±0.76c
	P4	237.98±0.50f	236.64±0.12f	235.97±0.06f	232.55±0.48de	214.18±0.34e
	P5	237.18±0.25f	236.54±0.02f	235.27±0.03f	231.55±0.78de	212.58±0.39e
	P6	274.89±0.02b	267.59±0.06b	255.91±0.71b	246.31±0.15a	242.86±0.50a
	P7	279.17±0.02a	272.00±1.28a	258.75±0.50a	248.23±0.10a	241.75±0.21a
	P8	267.98±0.02c	266.41±0.01b	252.27±0.21c	241.43±0.18b	227.39±0.02cd
	P9	257.91±0.01d	247.37±0.66d	243.26±0.22e	237.22±1.01c	226.38±0.47cd
	CK	237.48±0.04f	217.30±0.71g	217.05±1.06g	212.73±0.18g	204.68±0.16f
腐烂率/%	P1	5.33±0.01d	11.39±1.61a	13.13±0.18b	17.51±0.01d	26.48±0.03d
Decay rate	P2	8.00±0.14a	8.09±0.02d	11.32±0.02d	19.74±0.01c	36.51±0.01b
	P3	4.35±0.21e	10.29±0.07b	14.49±0.02a	23.74±0.02b	36.50±0.00b
	P4	7.32±0.02b	7.52±0.04ef	12.16±0.23c	19.15±0.21c	30.25±0.00c
	P5	6.32±0.02c	6.66±0.01g	9.34±0.00e	15.25±0.00e	26.12±0.17d
	P6	6.01±0.01c	8.01±0.01de	8.21±0.01f	16.25±0.00de	25.12±0.16e
	P7	5.74±0.02d	7.75±0.01e	8.20±0.00f	9.00±0.01f	15.00±0.00f
	P8	6.05±0.07c	8.32±0.02d	9.18±0.21e	19.76±0.01c	24.02±0.02e
	P9	4.01±0.01e	9.02±0.03c	11.12±0.17d	23.25±0.01b	30.24±0.01c
	CK	5.62±0.07d	10.60±0.85b	13.66±0.01b	31.35±0.21a	39.01±0.01a
硬度/(kg/cm²)	P1	1.72±0.10a	1.38±0.28a	1.27±0.03ab	1.12±0.10bc	0.95±0.03bc
Firmness	P2	1.78±0.10a	1.52±0.10a	1.25±0.20ab	1.24±0.11abc	1.02±0.20bc
	P3	1.67±0.14a	1.48±0.28a	1.15±0.12ab	1.06±0.09c	1.02±0.10bc
	P4	1.67±0.23a	1.62±0.09a	1.45±0.05a	1.43±0.13a	1.05±0.13bc
	P5	1.79±0.05a	1.64±0.23a	1.41±0.25a	1.24±0.03ab	1.23±0.11a
	P6	1.67±0.26a	1.60±0.25a	1.45±0.07a	1.42±0.07a	0.95±0.12bc
	P7	1.63±0.20a	1.49±0.35a	1.40±0.12a	1.36±0.08ab	1.06±0.18bc
	P8	1.73±0.12a	1.50±0.03a	1.11±0.26ab	1.11±0.17bc	1.09±0.20ab
	P9	1.61±0.20a	1.35±0.09a	1.18±0.16ab	1.15±0.28bc	1.09±0.10ab
	CK	1.58±0.08a	1.43±0.27a	1.00±0.19b	0.96±0.30c	0.88±0.18c

指标 Index	处理 Treatment	贮藏天数/d Storage time
指标 Index	处理 Treatment	1	2	3	4	5
TSS含量	P1	13.63±1.02b	14.17±1.46e	13.90±1.04d	13.50±2.29c	12.10±2.20d
TSS content	P2	12.20±1.82d	14.93±0.89c	13.30±1.87f	12.13±0.31f	12.10±0.59d
	P3	12.17±1.34d	14.83±2.47cd	13.67±1.43e	11.80±0.26g	11.47±0.80f
	P4	12.57±1.75cd	14.67±2.75d	12.93±1.59g	11.70±0.95g	11.07±0.31g
	P5	12.73±1.22c	15.30±0.90b	13.50±0.46ef	13.03±1.17d	12.77±1.22c
	P6	13.77±1.08ab	15.83±0.64a	14.60±2.63b	14.87±1.76a	14.57±2.00a
	P7	13.90±0.85a	15.87±1.10a	15.00±1.48a	14.03±1.59b	13.07±0.51b
	P8	12.50±1.31cd	15.37±0.76b	14.20±0.89c	12.27±0.51f	13.03±0.72b
	P9	12.07±0.76e	15.80±1.01a	14.20±1.50c	13.27±1.46c	11.77±0.61e
	CK	11.93±1.55f	14.33±1.61e	12.80±1.55g	12.73±0.57e	11.97±0.66d
SS含量	P1	0.525±0.009bcd	0.504±0.000c	0.420±0.009b	0.391±0.001b	0.380±0.001b
SS content	P2	0.529±0.002abc	0.515±0.001ab	0.421±0.002b	0.392±0.001b	0.382±0.001ab
	P3	0.524±0.001bcd	0.515±0.002ab	0.420±0.001b	0.389±0.001bc	0.382±0.000ab
	P4	0.529±0.019abc	0.506±0.003bc	0.422±0.019ab	0.390±0.003bc	0.375±0.004bc
	P5	0.522±0.002cd	0.492±0.002c	0.418±0.001b	0.388±0.002bc	0.367±0.002c
	P6	0.519±0.005cd	0.516±0.001ab	0.423±0.005ab	0.391±0.001b	0.377±0.001bc
	P7	0.539±0.001a	0.514±0.001ab	0.425±0.002a	0.398±0.001a	0.384±0.002a
	P8	0.537±0.002ab	0.504±0.003c	0.422±0.002ab	0.395±0.001ab	0.370±0.001c
	P9	0.523±0.001cd	0.521±0.001a	0.422±0.001ab	0.388±0.002bc	0.377±0.001bc
	CK	0.515±0.002d	0.476±0.015d	0.414±0.000c	0.384±0.015d	0.360±0.002d
TA含量	P1	0.464±0.121a	0.422±0.088a	0.394±0.142a	0.303±0.120a	0.288±0.156a
TA content	P2	0.550±0.168a	0.504±0.144a	0.462±0.048a	0.417±0.146a	0.370±0.124a
	P3	0.493±0.022a	0.461±0.023a	0.452±0.266a	0.404±0.241a	0.350±0.114a
	P4	0.511±0.019a	0.504±0.036a	0.447±0.072a	0.362±0.110a	0.338±0.014a
	P5	0.486±0.107a	0.426±0.037a	0.419±0.169a	0.407±0.161a	0.302±0.012a
	P6	0.592±0.185a	0.489±0.032a	0.482±0.212a	0.477±0.104a	0.389±0.040a
	P7	0.579±0.125a	0.516±0.227a	0.496±0.119a	0.481±0.116a	0.415±0.166a
	P8	0.571±0.064a	0.523±0.108a	0.464±0.143a	0.444±0.132a	0.355±0.026a
	P9	0.558±0.142a	0.400±0.150a	0.349±0.172a	0.435±0.264a	0.347±0.041a
	CK	0.441±0.004a	0.372±0.038a	0.318±0.055a	0.323±0.148a	0.320±0.016a

指标 Index	处理 Treatment	贮藏天数/d Storage time
指标 Index	处理 Treatment	1	2	3	4	5
TSS含量	P1	13.63±1.02b	14.17±1.46e	13.90±1.04d	13.50±2.29c	12.10±2.20d
TSS content	P2	12.20±1.82d	14.93±0.89c	13.30±1.87f	12.13±0.31f	12.10±0.59d
	P3	12.17±1.34d	14.83±2.47cd	13.67±1.43e	11.80±0.26g	11.47±0.80f
	P4	12.57±1.75cd	14.67±2.75d	12.93±1.59g	11.70±0.95g	11.07±0.31g
	P5	12.73±1.22c	15.30±0.90b	13.50±0.46ef	13.03±1.17d	12.77±1.22c
	P6	13.77±1.08ab	15.83±0.64a	14.60±2.63b	14.87±1.76a	14.57±2.00a
	P7	13.90±0.85a	15.87±1.10a	15.00±1.48a	14.03±1.59b	13.07±0.51b
	P8	12.50±1.31cd	15.37±0.76b	14.20±0.89c	12.27±0.51f	13.03±0.72b
	P9	12.07±0.76e	15.80±1.01a	14.20±1.50c	13.27±1.46c	11.77±0.61e
	CK	11.93±1.55f	14.33±1.61e	12.80±1.55g	12.73±0.57e	11.97±0.66d
SS含量	P1	0.525±0.009bcd	0.504±0.000c	0.420±0.009b	0.391±0.001b	0.380±0.001b
SS content	P2	0.529±0.002abc	0.515±0.001ab	0.421±0.002b	0.392±0.001b	0.382±0.001ab
	P3	0.524±0.001bcd	0.515±0.002ab	0.420±0.001b	0.389±0.001bc	0.382±0.000ab
	P4	0.529±0.019abc	0.506±0.003bc	0.422±0.019ab	0.390±0.003bc	0.375±0.004bc
	P5	0.522±0.002cd	0.492±0.002c	0.418±0.001b	0.388±0.002bc	0.367±0.002c
	P6	0.519±0.005cd	0.516±0.001ab	0.423±0.005ab	0.391±0.001b	0.377±0.001bc
	P7	0.539±0.001a	0.514±0.001ab	0.425±0.002a	0.398±0.001a	0.384±0.002a
	P8	0.537±0.002ab	0.504±0.003c	0.422±0.002ab	0.395±0.001ab	0.370±0.001c
	P9	0.523±0.001cd	0.521±0.001a	0.422±0.001ab	0.388±0.002bc	0.377±0.001bc
	CK	0.515±0.002d	0.476±0.015d	0.414±0.000c	0.384±0.015d	0.360±0.002d
TA含量	P1	0.464±0.121a	0.422±0.088a	0.394±0.142a	0.303±0.120a	0.288±0.156a
TA content	P2	0.550±0.168a	0.504±0.144a	0.462±0.048a	0.417±0.146a	0.370±0.124a
	P3	0.493±0.022a	0.461±0.023a	0.452±0.266a	0.404±0.241a	0.350±0.114a
	P4	0.511±0.019a	0.504±0.036a	0.447±0.072a	0.362±0.110a	0.338±0.014a
	P5	0.486±0.107a	0.426±0.037a	0.419±0.169a	0.407±0.161a	0.302±0.012a
	P6	0.592±0.185a	0.489±0.032a	0.482±0.212a	0.477±0.104a	0.389±0.040a
	P7	0.579±0.125a	0.516±0.227a	0.496±0.119a	0.481±0.116a	0.415±0.166a
	P8	0.571±0.064a	0.523±0.108a	0.464±0.143a	0.444±0.132a	0.355±0.026a
	P9	0.558±0.142a	0.400±0.150a	0.349±0.172a	0.435±0.264a	0.347±0.041a
	CK	0.441±0.004a	0.372±0.038a	0.318±0.055a	0.323±0.148a	0.320±0.016a

指标 Index	处理 Treatment	贮藏天数/d Storage time
指标 Index	处理 Treatment	1	2	3	4	5
Vc含量/(g/kg)	P1	0.90±0.03bcd	0.82±0.00c	0.68±0.01b	0.61±0.02b	0.49±0.01cd
Vc content	P2	0.99±0.01a	0.83±0.02bc	0.66±0.01cd	0.61±0.03b	0.47±0.01de
	P3	0.88±0.00cd	0.78±0.01d	0.66±0.80cd	0.61±0.01b	0.43±0.01ef
	P4	0.85±0.01d	0.75±0.03de	0.69±0.03b	0.57±0.06c	0.42±0.02f
	P5	0.92±0.03bc	0.83±0.01bc	0.67±0.01cd	0.62±0.00b	0.53±0.01bc
	P6	0.94±0.01ab	0.75±0.00de	0.73±0.00a	0.67±0.01a	0.55±0.01ab
	P7	0.95±0.04ab	0.95±0.01a	0.74±0.02a	0.68±0.02a	0.59±0.02a
	P8	0.90±0.01bcd	0.84±0.01b	0.73±0.02a	0.59±0.04bc	0.56±0.03ab
	P9	0.90±0.03bcd	0.78±0.01d	0.66±0.01cd	0.58±0.01c	0.52±0.01bc
	CK	0.85±0.01d	0.71±0.01f	0.63±0.01e	0.60±0.03bc	0.45±0.06ef
β-胡萝卜素含量/	P1	1.61±0.03d	1.59±0.01d	1.55±0.06c	1.54±0.01bc	1.37±0.01c
(mg/kg)	P2	1.74±0.02b	1.70±0.02c	1.60±0.02b	1.53±0.01bcd	1.44±0.02b
β- Carotene content	P3	1.67±0.02c	1.62±0.03d	1.50±0.03d	1.43±0.02cd	1.31±0.02d
	P4	1.76±0.02b	1.71±0.02c	1.59±0.02b	1.45±0.02bcd	1.28±0.02d
	P5	1.80±0.02ab	1.77±0.02b	1.61±0.01b	1.50±0.16bcd	1.38±0.04c
	P6	1.75±0.02b	1.69±0.02c	1.47±0.01de	1.43±0.01cd	1.14±0.02f
	P7	1.72±0.05bc	1.68±0.04c	1.59±0.03b	1.51±0.02bcd	1.22±0.02e
	P8	1.89±0.04a	1.83±0.06a	1.81±0.02a	1.76±0.02a	1.54±0.01a
	P9	1.65±0.00cd	1.68±0.02c	1.62±0.03b	1.56±0.08b	1.12±0.03f
	CK	1.49±0.02e	1.48±0.02e	1.58±0.03bc	1.42±0.03d	0.96±0.00g
SP含量/(g/kg)	P1	3.24±0.02h	3.14±0.04cd	2.97±0.04cd	2.69±0.04c	2.40±0.03f
SP content	P2	3.39±0.04e	3.14±0.03cd	2.80±0.04f	2.74±0.04b	2.33±0.05g
	P3	3.34±0.01f	2.99±0.06e	2.92±0.05de	2.45±0.02e	2.55±0.02d
	P4	3.14±0.02i	3.14±0.07cd	2.93±0.01de	2.69±0.03c	2.29±0.08h
	P5	3.22±0.02h	3.20±0.02bc	2.95±0.06cd	2.56±0.03d	2.46±0.01e
	P6	3.69±0.08a	3.32±0.01a	3.08±0.06a	2.69±0.04c	2.61±0.02b
	P7	3.44±0.03d	3.28±0.06ab	3.11±0.02a	2.58±0.06d	2.67±0.06a
	P8	3.62±0.02b	3.34±0.14a	3.05±0.02ab	2.65±0.02c	2.58±0.05c
	P9	3.59±0.00c	3.08±0.02d	3.00±0.01bc	2.93±0.02a	2.32±0.08g
	CK	3.28±0.01g	3.13±0.02cd	2.86±0.07ef	2.34±0.01f	2.24±0.06i

Please choose a citation manager

Content to export